I grew up in Clinton, Utah, when it was a sleepy farming community. Our one ward met in an old red brick chapel without air conditioning. Everyone knew everyone. Until the fifth grade, we had to drive to Sunset to fill our cars and trucks with fuel. It was a wonderful way to grow up.  

full-cinnamonMy mother made bread nearly every week. Often, she took part of the batch and made cinnamon rolls, bread dough wrapped around a mixture of cinnamon, sugar, and butter, cut into slices and baked. They were luscious. That’s my first memories of cinnamon and I’ve been in love with cinnamon ever since. With experience, I learned that nothing will make such a magical difference in your baking as a really good cinnamon.

There are so many different types of cinnamon available, many of them cheap and very inferior. A good cinnamon tastes good and a bad cinnamon tastes like a drug store. Once I found good cinnamon, I started doubling the amount called of in the recipe. In time I concluded that the reason so many recipes call for so little is that more bad cinnamon would destroy the recipe.

Today, I’ll help you choose a very good cinnamon. You’ll learn of different types of cinnamon and you’ll learn how much to buy and how to store it. And I’ll tell fourteen ways that you can fancy up those cinnamon rolls you make.

Would you like to try a really good cinnamon-for free? We’ll send you a four ounce shaker bottle, about one cup, of good Korintje Cassia cinnamon for the cost of shipping. Shipping will be only $2.99 to most locations. Only one freebie allowed per order

Types of Cinnamon

There are three types of cinnamon to consider: Korintje Cassia cinnamon, Vietnamese cinnamon, and Sri Lankan or Ceylon cinnamon.

  • Korintje cassia cinnamon comes from Indonesia, usually Sumatra. It comes from the cassia tree, not the true cinnamon tree, and is the cinnamon we are most familiar with. Good quality Korintje cassia is sweet and mellow. Lower quality cinnamon, the B and C grades commonly sold in the stores, is often bitter and astringent. You can tell the difference by tasting it. Dab a little on your finger and put it in your mouth. Premium Korintje cassia cinnamon will be smooth with an almost citrus tone.
  • Vietnamese (Saigon) cinnamon also come from the cassia tree but it has a very different tone resulting in a different experience when baked. Botanically, it is the same but is harvested and processed differently resulting in the different flavor. It is stronger and spicier with more cinnamon oil flavor. This is my favorite cinnamon in apple pies and apple desserts.
  • Ceylon (Sri Lankan) cinnamon is a true cinnamon coming from the cinnamon tree. In some parts of the world, it is preferred over cassia cinnamons. It is less pronounced in flavor and has a more citrus overtone.

Which cinnamon should I buy?

So which do you buy? We recommend all three so that you can match the distinctive flavors to recipes that you are using and the result you are trying to attain.

Korintje cassia is less expensive and can be very good. Be certain that you buy premium or grade A cinnamon. Look for the volatile oil content; that’s what gives cinnamon its flavor. It should have at least 2% volatile oil. (The cinnamon that we sell does.)

Shelf life: How much should I buy?

You have probably noticed that you can buy spices in bulk for much less than in small quantities. Handling and packaging is expensive. If you are confident in the quality of the cinnamon you are purchasing, buy it in quantity. However, keep in mind that cinnamon will lose its potency. As it becomes older, you may have to use more of it to get the same flavor in your goods. We recommend buying what you can use in a year.

Ideas for Your Next Cinnamon Roll Project

And now for those fancy ways to make cinnamon rolls: Mix your rolls as usual but add any of the following to your filling.

  1. Cranberry Nut Sweet Rolls.  Use dried cranberries and walnuts in the filling.  Add a little orange zest to your filling. 
  2. Cranapple Sweet Rolls.  Add dried cranberries and dried apples to your filling.  Alternatively, use an apple pastry filling and add cranberries.
  3. California Golden Sweet Rolls. Add golden raisins and orange zest to your filling. 
  4. Fruit Filled Sweet Rolls. Use a commercial fruit pastry filling with your sweet rolls. We sell apple, raspberry, blueberry, cherry, and lemon.  Alternatively, make your own filling with fresh fruit. 
  5. Maple Nut Sweet Rolls.  Make your filling with maple flavoring and walnuts. 
  6. Peanut Butter Sweet Rolls.  Instead of butter in the filling, substitute peanut butter.  Add chopped peanuts. 
  7. Chocolate Fudge Sweet Rolls.  Add cocoa to your dough and some extra sugar or add cocoa and chocolate chips to your filling.  Frost your rolls with a thick chocolate ganache. 
  8. Cinnamon Burst Sweet Rolls.  Add cinnamon chips to your filling.

Full-AppleCinnChipRolls

  1. Jammy Sweet Rolls.  Use your favorite jam or jelly in the filling. 
  2. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Sweet Rolls.  Make the fudge rolls above but substitute peanut butter for the butter and add extra peanut butter.
  3. Cherry Pecan Sweet Rolls. Add dried cherries or maraschino cherries and pecans to your filling.  Make a cherry frosting with red or pink food coloring and cherry extract.
  4. Pear and Pecan Sweet Rolls. Add dried pears and pecans to your filling. 
  5. Macadamia Orange Sweet Rolls.  Add macadamia nuts, white chocolate and orange marmalade to your filling.

      Add orange zest to a cream cheese frosting for topping.
  6. Coconut and Pecan Sweet Rolls.  Add shredded coconut and pecans to your filling.  Use brown sugar in the filling and omit the spices. 

Dennis Weaver is the founder of The Prepared Pantry. He is the author of How to Bake, a 250 page book about the art and science of baking. You can download a free copy of How to Bake here.