Tuesday, October 21 2014


menuClick Here
Erin Ann McBride
Tuesday, March 25 2014

Judge Whitaker: A Reel Legacy

By Erin Ann McBride Notify me when this author publishesComment on Article
Email Author
Author Archive
Send To a Friend
Print Article Bookmark and Share

His face can be seen carefully illustrated in Disney’s “Cinderella,” and he also directed “Johnny Lingo,” as well as the earlier temple films. Chances are that you have seen his work. Or at the very least, you’ve seen a film or video strongly influenced by him. But you’ve probably never heard his name – until now.

E wetzel

Wetzel “Judge” Whitaker was a Disney character animator in the 1950s. But a call from prophet and president David O. McKay changed that. Whitaker answered the call and left behind his lucrative career at the Disney studios to move to Utah and start a film studio for the Church and head up a film program at BYU. His career faced many trials from no film crews or sufficient funding, to building a state-of-the-art Hollywood style studio in the 1950’s. But what he left behind was a lasting legacy in LDS cinema that continues today.

In the film, “A Reel Legacy,” Whitaker’s mission as a father, husband, friend, and filmmaker legacy is honored through interviews with seventeen filmmakers, family members, and friends. The journey from the Walt Disney Studios to Provo, Utah is a true tale of faith, toil, sacrifice, and humility that will inspire as well as educate.


“A Reel Legacy” contains hundreds of never before seen images of Whitaker at Disney, and LDS Film Studios. Many of the images were thought to be either lost or non-existent. For various reasons, (including a massive fire), many explained in the film, much of the experiences of that time were not well documented.

Veteran filmmakers, including T.C. Christenson (“17 Miracles”) and Scott Swofford (“The Work and the Glory”), provide the first true glimpse into the life of someone who left a profound mark on the LDS culture and films. Until now, this film information about Whitaker was very hard to come by. All the research, stories, and photos in “A Reel Legacy” came together as an answer to prayer in helping the filmmakers be guided to know where to look and how. The interviews in the film tell stories that have never been shared before on screen, some of which are remarkable in scale, a testimony that the Lord was watching over this group at that time.

The film, available on DVD, premiered at the 2012 BYU Mormon Media Symposium, and at the 2012 LDS Film Festival, and has gone on to win "Best of State 2013” in documentary, plus won three Aurora Awards.

E Judge BobStum

For film buffs, or even just those interested in the cinematic history of the LDS church, this film offers an authentic, real glimpse into what ‘independent’ filmmaking was like back in the 1950’s. The story of the early years of LDS filmmaking has been largely untold – until now. This documentary offers insights into that unique filmmaking history from the filmmakers’ point of view through interviews with many of those original filmmakers and their protégés.

“A Reel Legacy” is available from Amazon for $12.95.

A Reel Legacy - Trailer from Workman Productions on Vimeo.

An Interview with Filmmaker Tom Laughlin

Question: What is your relationship to Judge Whitaker? What made you choose him as a film subject?

You know, it's actually a funny story, I moved out to Utah from Wichita, and came out here to be a filmmaker, and had no money, no friends, just flew out here in 2003 and started to meet the local filmmakers and get involved in the local film scene. I tried to get into BYU Film School back, but was turned down due to the amount of students also trying and spots were full. My apartment was right down the street from the LDS Motion Picture Studio, and I'd often walk on through security and get on little film shoots here and there. I did some Production Assistant work on a few small 2-3 day projects at the studio, one of them being the updated "First Vision" (2005). Though I was not able to spend a ton of time on projects, I was able to roam the studio lot, in my spare time, and also the studio's main office, where all the editing was happening.

E PeterPan

How I discovered Judge was unusual. As you know, he passed away many years ago. One day I was asked by a producer while on a shoot, to go inside the main office to make some photo copies. I wondered around for a few minutes, and found myself curiously exploring a long dark hallway, with no lights on. I walked all the way down this long hallway, and stopped at the low light 'exit' sign of a back door. To my surprise, on the wall to my right, was a very small old wooden framed black and white picture of a man. His face looked so familiar to me though I'd never seen him before in my life. He seemed to be smiling at me.

E KimballJudge Whitaker with President Kimball

I became curious, as I'd never heard of this man, Judge Whitaker. That photo remained on the wall for several more years. About 10 years later, I was back at the studio, went down the same hallway. The picture still hung and dusty. At that point, I not only remembered my first encounter with this picture about 10 years previous, but I also became more and more interested in him, as well as the untold and forgotten history of this studio, and who all helped build it, and where they came from, and how all this Church Media came to be.

No one knew!

E McKayJudge Whitaker with President McKay

I was able to visit with some people at the Church, who were supportive of my project, and turning this research into a documentary about Judge.


  1. Nice article, but PLEASE be more edit-conscious. There were so many sub-quality errors that got in the way of the material at hand. I love Judge Whitaker, but would have enjoyed the article much better had there been more rigorous editing.
  2. I pushed camaera for him one day in 1957 at the first temporary studio and learned many lighting tricks that I later used.
  3. In 1954 I was a booking clerk in the BYU film library that rented educational films to school ditricts. Judge Whitaker frequently came into the office to visit the officials there for advice or instructions. Always remembered him for taste, dignity, courtesy, manners, humility and class.
  4. Wow! What an amazing thing I never knew about. Anxious to get the DVD. Pretty amazing story on filmmakers accomplished this. I'm surprised we don't know much about this history already. Intriguing.
  5. So sorry everyone! It appears the link to Amazon is faulty and Amazon has sold out! If you would like to buy the DVD, you can also find it at Deseret Book - deseretbook.com/Reel-Legacy-HaleStone/i/5099011
  6. I, too, am anxious to see the DVD. My brother David, and I appeared in one of his first films in the late 1940s which was about Welfare Services in southern California. My father, W. Cleon Skousen, was instrumental in getting Judge Whitaker to come to BYU in 1952. Great memories and many thanks for the article.
  7. Back in 1955-56 the film studio was a very temporary building on the North East part of the campus. The first film was called "Teaching with Chalk" and "How near to the Angels" was one of the other early films. Judge Whitaker and his brother were very nice and allowed me to push the camera man on the dolly for some of the filming.
  8. Chances are that anyone that knows anything about the history of filmmaking at BYU knows his name. (You should give folks a little more credit.) Great things were accomplished by him.
  9. He was a pioneer in the truest sense of the word !
  10. I was cast in two films by Judge Whitaker at the nascent BYUI film studio when I was a small red headed boy in Provo in the early 50's . He and his brother Scotty were so kind and supportive that it remains one of my favorite memories of the Provo Valley. One of the films was completed - about home teaching - but I was told by Scotty that it wasn't used much because President McKay didn't like the notion in it that some home teachers were not very faithful in their callings. Ah! The memories the name Wetzel O Whitaken brings to me.
  11. I remember him from BYU in the 50s. Thanks for the article. I'm going to order the DVD.
  12. I remember people asking me if I was related to the famous LDS film maker Judge Whitaker and his don Scott who was also involved in film making . My dad told me that Judge was his Uncle. I thought that was so cool that I could tell my friends while watching the credits of the LDS films that I was related to him . Interesting fact is that my brother was a famous Hollywood movie star at that time , but I was more impressed that Judge was my great uncle . Life is so interesting isn't it?

Add Comment