|
Share the article on
this page with a friend.
Click
here.
|
|

Click here to sign up for Meridian's FREE email updates.
Criticism or Critique?
By Susan Law Corpany
As a writer, I have learned that in order to hone my craft, I have to be able to endure occasionally being told ways I can improve my writing. Not only that, but I have to learn to welcome such input in order to turn out a better finished product. Occasionally in a letter of rejection there is a confirmation of something I do well and perhaps a hint of something on which I need to work. Over the years, I have learned to value the opinions of those with more experience and different insights who share techniques that help me become a better writer. Many authors belong to groups where they meet regularly and read excerpts from their works-in-progress and help one another to improve by sharing thoughts about what might make the writing more authentic, more moving, and more polished. Some writers even go so far as to pay someone to critique their work. This is usually someone accomplished, someone with literary skills and know-how, someone higher up the mountain. How crazy do you have to be to actually pay someone to criticize you?
Lucky for most of us, the service can usually be had for free. None of us likes criticism, however, and harsh, unrelenting, unkind criticism is never productive, whether from our friends, our spouse or our enemies. I venture to say, though, that virtually all of us could benefit from a thoughtful critique now and then. The first thing I always have to do when one of my faults is brought to my attention in a loving way is fight down the natural man urge to be offended or defensive, making excuses and continuing in the error of my ways.
At those times, I remind myself of these scriptures in
Proverbs 9: 8 & 9
8 Reprove not a scorner, lest he hate three; rebuke a wise man, and he will love thee.
9 Give instruction to a wise man, and he will be yet wiser: teach a just man and he will increase in learning.
In other words, smart people learn from the thoughtful input of others.
Here are the things I believe we need to learn to do in order to accept helpful suggestions and overcome faults.
Be Self-aware
I am repeatedly late for events, especially those involving family. Recently my son told me, “Mom, when you show up late for something that is supposed to be important to me, that tells me it isn't that important to you.” Ouch! I had what I thought was a legitimate excuse that day. In fact, I always have an excuse at the ready, enabling me to continue in error indefinitely if I convince myself that the situation is out of my control. It isn't. It is my own bad habit, cultivated for years. My husband has also gently suggested that I need to learn that both time and money can only be spent once. A first step to improving in any area is admitting to yourself that the fault exists.
Avoid Retaliation
When we feel we are being fired upon, we often fire back, usually without thinking. If we can bring up a shortcoming that person has or otherwise shift the blame, we can avoid doing anything about our own behavior.
Don't Become Defensive
If it is an ingrained habit, we have likely already spent many years justifying to ourselves the reasons why we are the way we are. If we become defensive, there is likely little hope of change. Until we can examine our own behavior honestly and fairly, we won't begin to work on improving.
Consider the Source(s)
As a writer, I have learned that when I am able to put my ego aside and listen to the suggestions of others, I end up with a better finished product. When someone I love brings something to my attention, and I know they love me, I try to assume their motives are for me to end up as a better finished product. If the same opinion comes to me over a period of time from more than one source, I consider that there must be some validity in the assessment. Either that, or I consider a conspiracy theory.
Have Friends in High Places
Ether 12: 27
27 And if men come unto me I will show unto them their weakness. I give unto men weakness that they may be humble; and my grace is sufficient for all men that humble themselves before me; for if they humble themselves before me, and have faith in me, then will I make weak things become strong unto them.
The word “humble” appears three times in this verse. That should tell us something. Perhaps it is that the Author of this scripture ought to get out His thesaurus, because then He would avoid repeating the same words over and over in His writing.
Then again, maybe not.
One of my favorite bishops was a young man who stood before the congregation and requested “Be patient with me as your bishop. I haven't even toilet-trained a child yet.” Because he approached that important assignment (bishop, not toilet training) knowing he had much to learn, he was humble and teachable, something we all need to be in order to be more effective leaders, more diligent followers and better people.
President Gordon B. Hinckley said it best:
Accentuate the Positive
I come to you tonight with a plea that we stop seeking out the storms and enjoy more fully the sunlight. I am suggesting that as we go through life we try to 'accentuate the positive.' I am asking that we look a little deeper for the good, that we still our voices of insult and sarcasm, that we more generously compliment virtue and effort. Now I am not asking that all criticism be silenced. Growth comes of correction. Strength comes of repentance. Wise is the man or woman who can acknowledge mistakes pointed out by others and change his or her course. What I am suggesting is that you turn from the negativism that so permeates our modern society and look for the remarkable good among those with whom you associate, that we speak of one another's virtues more than we speak of one another's faults, that optimism replace pessimism, that our faith exceed our fears. When I was a young man and was prone to speak critically, my wise father would say: 'Cynics do not contribute. Skeptics do not create. Doubters do not achieve.'
From Be Not Afraid, Only Believe, CES Fireside for Young Adults, Sept. 9, 2001
Susan will be available to meet Meridian readers
On Tuesday, June 9,
she will be at the Brick Oven Pizza restaurant
111 E. 800 North, Provo, from 6:30 to 8:30.
Come, bring a friend. Get a free book.
Return
to Top of Article
Click
here to sign up for Meridian's FREE email updates.
© 1999-2009 Meridian
Magazine. All Rights Reserved.
|
|
| About
the Author: |
|

Susan Law Corpany grew up in Salt Lake City. She attended Utah State University and the University of Utah, and she is currently attending the University of Hawaii at Hilo, on the big island of Hawaii, where she now lives. She is married to Thom Curtis, a sociology professor at UHH. She has one son, a stepdaughter and five stepsons. She recently became a grandmother to the world's most beautiful baby girl and will, on request, furnish the e-mail addresses of her unmarried returned missionary sons to eligible young ladies in an attempt to get more such wonderful grandbabies.
She has stored up a half century of wit and wisdom and began a couple of decades ago to download it onto the printed page. Widowed in her twenties, a series of books resulted from the experience. She is the author of Brotherly Love, Unfinished Business, Push On and Are We There Yet? She considers herself sort of a cross between Erma Bombeck and Eliza R. Snow and says she writes under her first married name "To honor my first husband and not to embarrass my current one." She is currently working on several other novels, and is collaborating on a humorous self-help book called, "Why Don't the Airlines Ever Lose My Emotional Baggage?"
|
| Related
Resources: |
|
A Beacon Light Archive
Click toBuy

Click to Buy
|
| What
do you think? |
| Share
your thoughts, feelings, comments, and impressions about this article. |
Format
for Print
Click Here |
To easily share the article on this page with friends and family, please
Click here.
|
|
 |
| |
|